Did Joseph Smith Fake the Gold Plates? Dan Vogel Breaks It Down
Hey everyone, I’m Dives, and welcome back to The Mormon News Roundup.
Today, we’re breaking down a fascinating deep-dive from historian Dan Vogel on one of the most iconic claims in Mormonism: the Book of Mormon gold plates.
His original video runs over an hour—but in this episode, I cut through the noise and give you the most important insights in a clear, digestible format.
🎥 Watch Dan Vogel’s Original Video
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qEwzcMEzOaU&t=1s
👇 What This Video Covers
👉 If Joseph Smith fabricated the plates… how would he have actually done it using 1820s technology?
In this breakdown, we explore:
The real-world difficulty of creating metal plates in the 1820s
Why most witnesses never saw the plates uncovered
How materials like tin, copper, or shingles could match descriptions
The strange “greenish” appearance reported by early witnesses
A modern tin plate replica experiment matching reported weight
Why the plates may only have needed to look convincing through a cloth or inside a box
And what Joseph Smith’s neighbors didn’t say that might matter
🧠 Key Takeaway
Dan Vogel argues something nuanced:
Fully gold, engraved plates? Highly implausible
A partially concealed, convincingly weighted object? Much more plausible
This aligns with historical accounts suggesting the plates were often covered, boxed, or only partially seen, which lowers the bar for what needed to be physically created.
💬 Join the Discussion
Do you think the plates were:
Genuine ancient artifacts?
A physical prop?
Something more complicated?
Drop your thoughts in the comments 👇
Please consider making a donation by joining our Patreon https://www.patreon.com/MormonNewsRoundup
Email: kolob@mormonnewsroundup.org
Website: https://mormonnewsroundup.org/
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@mormonnewsroundup
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/mormon_news_roundup/
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/dives.lazarus/
X: https://twitter.com/NewsMormon
New episodes every night at 9:30 PM Eastern.
Please like and subscribe and hit the notifications bell. Remember remember, no unhallowed hand can stop this podcast from progressing!
The Mormon News Roundup is NOT affilated with the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.